We’ve spent some time analyzing the veterans coming back to the Braves this season, but our focus today turns to the 22 year old Mallex Smith, who was a single short of the cycle (with two triples!) on Wednesday against the Orioles in the 2nd Grapefruit League game for the Atlanta club. Here we see Smith’s offensive numbers by minor league level.
He has been truly great, but to put these into context, let’s see the next chart which converts each number into a 600 at bat season. Each fraction is rounded down to the nearest integer and batting average is recalculated.
The last row is a linear regression of the various seasons into the next level (a mythical AAAA league). This isn’t really a good estimate of how Smith will produce in the majors for lots of reasons. Research has shown that lower minor league stats are less predictive of major league success than higher minor league stats, and the difference in pitching between AAA and the majors is much greater than the difference between AA and AAA, etc., etc.
In any case, it is interesting that Michael Bourn is mentoring Smith in spring training, because they seem like very similar players. Let’s look at Bourn’s defense by looking at Range Factor per 9 innings over his career in center field.
He started out at or above the league range factor, and as of 2013 has been below it and falling. If we isolate Bourn and Smith’s minors-only fielding numbers we can see the following comparison.
It would appear that Smith’s ceiling might be a roughly equal offensive player to Bourn, but a slightly slower defensive center fielder with a few more errors. That will be well worth it to the Braves if the Braves’ coaching staff can get the potential out of Smith.